Can Homework Actually Hurt Your Grades?

Monday, January 8, 2018

Wake up. Get dressed. Eat breakfast. Go to class for seven hours. Run six miles. Come home. Shower. Eat. Work on homework. Study. Go to bed. Repeat. 

I’m sure if you asked most high school students in America, their schedule would have a similar resemblance to this. With this overloaded schedule, where is there any free time to hang out with friends, go to an athletic event, or even just spend some much-needed family time? We are living in a world where students are overzealously pressured to perform at high standards and are expected to be well rounded at the same time. A recent study by the American Psychological Association shows that teenagers are more stressed than adults during the school year. If future generations are continually put under this amount of pressure and their stress stays at this tremendously high level, their future will be riddled with other health issues. 

Imagine coming home after a seven hour day at school and a two hour practice, and then realizing that you have three and a half hours of homework and studying to do. You are already tired from your long day and you really don’t feel like doing your homework, but you know if you don’t do it you will get even more behind. Between the time spent at school, sports, and homework, 12 and a half hours of your day are taken up. Plus you know that you need to get a good amount of sleep so that you can focus tomorrow at school. The National Sleep Foundation says that teenagers need at least nine hours of sleep per night but says that less than 15 percent of teenagers even get eight hours of sleep per night. This lack of sleep leads to mood swings, drowsy driving, and worsened academic performance. America’s test scores are right around the middle of the international range, and this mediocre performance could be attributed to an overwhelming amount of stress on our students with little to no downtime. 

In 2007, 59 countries participated in the Trends in Mathematics and Science Study, of these 59 countries, East Asia, Hong Kong, Taiwan and Japan, who are all among the top 10 in both mathematics and science scores, reported data, which was below the international average, for time spent on work outside of school. Does this data show the connection between less homework and better grades? A group of researchers based in Australia have made it their goal to find this out. One of the most influential scientists in the group, Richard Walker, an educational physicist at Sydney University, stated that, while participating in the PISA, a standardized test taken in multiple countries, most students with higher scores had spent less time on homework. This same result has consistently shown up in other tests. These results are a pretty good answer to the question of a connection between higher tests score and less homework, but not only does this excess stress affect performances in school, it also has significant effects on the physical and mental health of the students. 

According to a survey done every year by the CDC on youth risk behavior, one out of every six teenagers has considered suicide and one out of every 12 have attempted to kill themselves. Some of these attempts can be attributed to the overwhelming stress and pressure put on students to do so much. Less than 1 percent of students said they didn’t consider school a stressor and 56 percent accredited most of their stress to school work. Stanford University says that this number is higher in upper and middle-class families because they are in more difficult schools and feel as if they have more pressure on them. This stress can lead to a serious health issue called distress. Distress causes headaches, high blood pressure, upset stomach, and trouble sleeping. Harris Cooper, a professor of Psychology and Neuroscience at Duke University, suggests that in order for students to not become so overwhelmed, a second grader should spend between 10-15 minutes on work outside of school per night, and this amount should increase by only 10-15 minutes each year. 

"When I talk to parents … they want their kids to be well-rounded, creative, happy individuals — not just kids who ace the tests,” stated Gerald LeTendre, a professor at Pennsylvania State University. He also says that since most homework has a pretty neutral or even negative effect on grades, students should participate in other activities such as sports or music in order to learn other beneficial skills. Amil Khelil, an alumnus of Rochester University, writes that sports provide an outlet for students to relax, get fit, have fun, and make new friends. However it does not only help people in the present, it also helps in the long term by teaching them accountability, teamwork, and working to accomplish a goal (Benefits of Sports to Students). These skills come in handy just as much if not more than those learned in school in the workplace. 

Although too much homework can put a great amount of stress on students, Walker found that it is beneficial to students in the 10th-12th grades. It is important to these older students because it starts to prepare them for college and life in the working world away from home. Students who complete their homework assignments are also more engaged in school, but they are under more stress so they could end up with stress-related health problems in the future. 

If we do not address this issue of students being put under too much stress, the students of today, who will one day be the leaders of our world, will have both mental and physical illnesses that have never been dealt with at such a high rate, and will be even farther behind the countries, who are paying attention to this rising problem.

Benjamin Niehaus

Elect Leaders To Preserve Signal Mountain's Small Town Character

Dear Signal Mountain Residents,  Do you care deeply about preserving Signal Mountain's natural beauty and small town character? We do. Over the past year, the town has faced requests to rezone residential properties for commercial use.   These requests might have been approved by the majority of our council, if not for the multitude of residents speaking out against ... (click for more)

East Brainerd For Joda Thongnopnua

Joda Thongnopnua has my vote for District 30 State House of Representatives. I have supported both Republicans and Democrats in the past and I’m very happy that someone of Joda’s caliber is running for this open seat. I have worked alongside Joda professionally and I’ve seen firsthand his work ethic and his great ability to work with others to come up with the best solution.  ... (click for more)

Soddy Daisy High ROTC Instructor Denies He Had Gun In Road Rage Incident, But Judge Sends Case To Grand Jury

A Soddy Daisy ROTC instructor has denied having a gun in a road rage incident with a 17-year-old girl at Northgate Mall, but General Sessions Court Judge Gary Starnes bound the case to the Grand Jury. The judge said,"It's a very close issue. It's he said, she said. I don't think it's going to get out of the Grand Jury, but I am going to find there is probable cause." The girl ... (click for more)

Federal Judge In Nashville Tells State To Halt Suspension Of Drivers Licenses Of Those Who Cannot Pay

 A Nashville federal judge has directed that the state halt suspension of the drivers licenses of people who cannot afford to pay fines and court costs. The ruling was from District Judge Aleta Trauger. Officials of the Department of Safety and Homeland Security said, "The department has received the order.  It will stop suspensions of licenses, as the Court requires, ... (click for more)

Knox Catholic Ends East Hamilton's Bid For Class 2A State Volleyball Title

MURFREESBORO, Tenn. – East Hamilton’s bid to reach the TSSAA Class 2A state tournament title game was dashed Wednesday night when the Lady Hurricanes fell to Knoxville Catholic, 3-0, for the second time in as many days. Scores were 25-23, 25-22 and 25-17. “It’s hard to come back after playing a really good match like we did against Camden,” East Hamilton coach Bojana Hyatt ... (click for more)

Sale Creek Whips Watertown, 3-0, For Shot At First Class 1A State Volleyball Title

MURFREESBORO, Tenn. – Sale Creek wasn’t ready to head home short of its ultimate goal. And the roadblock Hickman County put up was nothing but a diminutive speed bump. Sale Creek (38-7) used its fast-paced attack to overwhelm the Lady Bulldogs, 3-0, Wednesday afternoon and remained alive in the loser’s bracket of the TSSAA Class 1A state volleyball tournament at Middle Tennessee ... (click for more)